How Cities Can Combat the Dangerous Combination of Extreme Heat and COVID
Labor Day Weekend usually signals the end of summer, but this year, it seems like the record heat isn鈥檛 ready to release its grip quite yet. Another heat wave is on its way, signaling how our climate is changing. Almost all of California, along with southern Nevada, western New Mexico, and even eastern North Carolina are under 鈥溾 from the National Weather Service through the long weekend. Temperatures are expected to be as much as 22 degrees Fahrenheit above the averages for this time of year, increasing the risk for wildfires, power outages, and heat-related illness.
鈥淓xtreme heat can be deadly, especially for vulnerable populations,鈥 says Melissa Baldwin, program manager for Florida Clinicians for Climate Action, adding that 鈥渃oronavirus is shining a light on existing inequities and health outcomes.鈥
The compounding threats of heat and isolation have been laid bare this summer thanks to COVID-19. Many elders are stuck inside, and those experiencing homelessness are stuck outside鈥攂oth facing heat exposure, many of them alone.
As the Trump administration鈥檚 actions threaten public health and safety, cities and states are finding new ways to keep their residents cool and safe this summer and beyond.
Our Warming Climate
Though it gets far less attention than other disasters, heat is , surpassing the number of fatalities from hurricanes, tornadoes, or floods.
鈥淐limate change鈥攊n the form of longer, more intense heat waves鈥攊s threatening our health right now, and it’s going to get a lot worse,鈥 Baldwin says.
Exposure to heat and a lack of ventilation can cause myriad health problems, including heat exhaustion, hyperthermia, dehydration, and heatstroke. These conditions can be serious or even deadly, especially if layered on top of existing chronic health conditions. People who live in cooler climes are also less able to adjust to unseasonable heat.
The northern hemisphere experienced in 2020, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, with some very serious repercussions. The average high temperature in Phoenix, for example, was 110 degrees Fahrenheit, and it failed to cool down at night, often staying above 90 degrees. While daytime temperature spikes may seem the most dangerous, the effects of heat are often felt most acutely on warmer-than-usual nights. Heat is linked to many breathing problems that are exacerbated at night, like COPD and sleep apnea.
As is the case with COVID-19, elders are at a higher risk of heat death. As we age, our cardiovascular systems weaken, and our bodies regulate internal temperature less effectively. Of the 12,000 Americans who , 80% are 60 years or older. And that demographic is on the rise in the U.S.
Heat鈥檚 effects are , where hard surfaces like streets, sidewalks, and buildings store heat, only to release it later. The impact of these heat islands is felt acutely by those experiencing homelessness, and the pandemic is expected . That, paired with the higher rates of physical and mental health conditions, makes these populations particularly vulnerable to the effects of heat. Having a preexisting psychiatric illness, for example, , according to one study.
Thanks to structural racism in U.S. housing and healthcare, these disparities also break along racial lines. Black, Indigenous, and people of color in the U.S. as well as .
Pandemic-induced Isolation
Today, as the world is entering month seven of some version of lockdown, people who were already isolated before the pandemic now have even less interaction with the outside world. That includes the 14.3 million.
鈥淗ere in Illinois, home-health workers didn鈥檛 feel comfortable going into their clients鈥 homes,鈥 says Alexa James, CEO of the Chicago-based mental health provider NAMI. The city of Chicago has a plan for when the heat index is high, requiring routine wellness checks for homeless, elderly, and disabled residents as well as the opening of six cooling centers and 50 cooling buses, among other solutions. But COVID-19 introduces new challenges. 鈥淒ue to pre-existing conditions, the elderly may have access to cooling places but are afraid to leave their homes for fear of attracting the virus, or general anxiety,鈥 James says.
Staying home comes with its own risks, especially for the more than . Being able to afford an air conditioner and the associated costs on their utility bills remains out of reach for many. Of the people who died indoors due to heat in 2019 in Maricopa County, Arizona, which includes Phoenix, that was either broken, turned off, or didn鈥檛 have electricity.
Part of the challenge of addressing the risks of heat during a pandemic is that nobody knows what cities are going to look like a week, a month, or three months from now.
That鈥檚 where public buildings and community spaces have historically stepped in. In a usual summer, cities across the U.S. open up libraries, post offices, and other public buildings as cooling centers. But now, in our socially distant realities, many of these resources are closed due to the coronavirus.
鈥淐OVID, and Amazon to some extent, [have] shuttered America’s shopping malls,鈥 says Jonathan Parfrey, executive director of the Los Angeles-based nonprofit Climate Resolve. 鈥淚n years past, malls have served as unofficial cooling centers. Today, they’re no longer an option.鈥
Post Offices have long been a go-to spot to cool down, but the Trump administration has blocked crucial USPS funding. Many libraries did a slow reopen after the virus first came to U.S. shores, with fewer open hours and extra cleaning. But soon after, some, like the branches in Queens, New York, were forced to re-close as Tropical Storm Isaias made landfall. In nearby New Jersey, at the Jersey City Free Public Library, after a few weeks of improvised services like curbside delivery, one of the ten branches closed again due to power outages from the storm. The other nine provided emergency response, opening their doors to patrons to charge devices and use public computers.
Moving Targets
Part of the challenge of addressing the risks of heat during a pandemic is that nobody knows what cities are going to look like a week, a month, or three months from now. In April, New York was seeing as many as , but by mid-June the number of new cases decreased to 600 a day, where it has hovered ever since. Other states, like Florida, lagged in their initial number of cases but have since skyrocketed to . Plus, rules vary significantly between states and are changing all the time. All this amid a total absence of national leadership.
That has left it up to local leaders to come up with their own fixes. On May 29, then the hottest day of the year, Phoenix with socially distant tables and chairs set up inside. During a city-wide public health emergency declared in Philadelphia on July 20鈥攖he first heat-related emergency in its history鈥攖he city opened cooling centers from 1 to 5 PM: two schools, three libraries, and four regional buses, parked with the A/C running.
Still, these are temporary solutions, rife with bureaucratic issues that stem from poor policy, underfunding, politicization of disenfranchised communities and climate change, and simple political leadership. 鈥淚n Florida, we have a lot of people who don鈥檛 have adequate housing, and they can鈥檛 afford a new air conditioner or [to] replace their windows,鈥 says Baldwin, of Florida Clinicians for Climate Action. Nearly 60% of Miami residents live paycheck-to-paycheck, which puts them , as reported by NPR. And that鈥檚 only getting worse with unemployment benefits in limbo.
Retrofitting homes with better insulation and energy-efficient cooling systems could be a win-win, according to Baldwin. In Massachusetts, Sen. Ed Markey (who just won a Democratic Senate primary race against Joe Kennedy III) introduced legislation on July 22 to offer . New York City is already on its way to addressing these challenges, providing free air conditioners to low-income seniors who pre-qualify based on their enrollment in benefits programs.
Increased access to air conditioning promises more positive health outcomes, but also contributes to a warming climate. Operating air-conditioners about 100 million tons of carbon dioxide each year as well as HFCs, or hydrofluorocarbons, which erode the ozone layer. By expanding a program like New York鈥檚 to include energy efficiency upgrades, Baldwin says it could help people recover from the pandemic, improve the quality of homes, create jobs for communities of color, and preserve a livable climate.
Beyond policies, social connections, too, can save lives. Check in on neighbors, relatives, and friends. Many heat deaths can be prevented with actions as simple as a glass of cool water or a few clicks on the thermostat. 鈥淭his isn鈥檛 a totally hopeless story,鈥 says James of NAMI, who also serves on the Chicago mayor鈥檚 COVID-19 task force. 鈥淲e all could be healers. A lot of people want to do good right now. If we could connect with one person every day, it would be meaningful.鈥
Additional reporting by Breanna Draxler.
CORRECTION: This article was updated at 10:24 a.m. on Sept. 8, 2020, to reflect that during the extended power outage from Tropical Storm Isaias, the Jersey City Free Public Library only closed one of its branches rather than many. Read our corrections policy here.
Eli Reiter
is a graduate student at the University of Chicago, and a writer, storyteller, and educator whose work focuses on climate, income inequality, politics, religion, and culture. His commentary and essays have appeared in The New York Times, Business Insider, Slate, and The Washington Post, among other outlets. He is based in Chicago and New York, and speaks English and Hebrew. He is currently writing a book, and can be contacted at elireiter.com.
|