News Based on facts, either observed and verified directly by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Analysis Based on factual reporting, although it incorporates the expertise of the author/producer and may offer interpretations and conclusions.
The Yurok Tribe Is Using California鈥檚 Carbon Offset Program to Buy Back Its Land
In January, the Yurok Tribe in California bought a . Located next to an elementary school and the tribe鈥檚 Head Start program, the farm will serve as an outdoor classroom for children as well as a source of . This will not only help address the food insecurity exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic, but it is also part of the tribe鈥檚 bid to reclaim its ancestral territory.
Land is important to Native nations for myriad reasons. Land enables the Yurok to maintain cultural traditions such as gathering traditional foods and practicing place-specific religious ceremonies. Like all sovereign entities, land defines the Yurok as a nation, both culturally and politically. Land offers economic development opportunities. It also bolsters climate resilience as the tribe restores wetlands, coastal prairies, and old-growth forests using traditional land management techniques.
In the past three and a half decades, the tribal land base has grown twentyfold, to a total of 100,000 acres, funded in large part by sequestering carbon. For this work, the United Nations Development Programme awarded the Yurok Tribe its , which recognizes efforts that reduce poverty through environmental justice work. It鈥檚 an exciting example of a small community鈥攁bout 5,000 members are enrolled鈥攂uilding climate resiliency in a way that best fits their needs.
鈥淲hen I was a young man growing up on the reservation, all of our land laid behind locked gates,鈥 says tribal Vice Chairman Frankie Myers. 鈥淲e鈥檇 have to break into our land in order to get into our prayer sites. In order to get to our gathering sites, we had to be outlaws. My kids growing up will never have that feeling. My wife can gather without worrying about being harassed by law enforcement or a logging company.鈥
The Tribe鈥檚 Quest for its Traditional Territory
The Yurok Tribe has long faced state and federal policies meant to eliminate its land base. Before American colonization and conquest, the tribal territory stretched along what is now the Northern California coast and inland within the Klamath River watershed.
The in the 1840s drew white settlers West, where they killed of Native people through forced displacement, enslavement, and disease. In the 20th century, the Yurok continued to be denied access to their land and water, leading to over fishing rights. By 1986, when they finally gained federal recognition, the tribe was returned鈥攁bout 1% of its traditional territory.
For these reasons, 鈥渙ur number one priority is to get our land back,鈥 Myers says. In 2011, the tribe used to buy about 32,000 acres in the and watersheds, which had been owned by a timber company. The watersheds were selected both because of their biodiversity and old growth forests, according to Myers, and because the areas were used in Yurok religious ceremonies.
This purchase more than quadrupled their land base, but also meant the tribe owed the state government millions of dollars. They originally planned to pay back their loans by sustainably logging the land, but that would have taken a long time. 鈥淲e needed to be creative about how we were going to attack this problem,鈥 Myers says. 鈥淲e needed to be courageous in leaning into what we had.鈥
They soon found a creative solution. In 2010 and 2011, the California Air Resources Board (ARB) was conducting a formal rule-making process to create a . Cap-and-trade programs allow industries that cannot otherwise reach their emission compliance requirements to purchase credits, called offsets, from sellers that sequester greenhouse gases. (In California, industries can use credits to offset up to 8% of their emissions.)
The ARB did not initially engage with tribes because they were focusing on land where the state had enforcement jurisdiction. At that time, Jason Gray, now head of the state鈥檚 cap-and-trade program, had just joined ARB as an attorney to advise on offset protocol design. 鈥淭he Yurok, rightly so, came to us and said, 鈥楽hame on you guys. Why aren鈥檛 you including us?鈥欌 he recalls. The state listened, and the Yurok and several other tribes provided feedback to ensure the program worked within the structures of tribal law while fulfilling the state鈥檚 need to enforce regulatory standards. In 2013, when the cap-and-trade program formally launched, the Yurok became the first entity in the state to register a forest offset project.
Participation in the program has been a huge success for the Yurok. With income from the offset program, the Yurok have paid off loans from their previous watershed purchases; supported youth programming, housing, and road improvement; and helped develop off-reservation businesses such as in Humboldt County, California. They have also been able to buy back tens of thousands of acres of their traditional territory, which has had a powerful impact on the tribal nation.
鈥淚t鈥檚 quite amazing what the Yurok have accomplished,鈥 Gray says.
A Holistic View of Forest Management
The Yurok鈥檚 small land base was once heavily logged by private timber companies and co-managed by agencies such as the U.S. Forest Service, who viewed land management from a fundamentally different perspective than the Yurok.
For example, the Yurok view fire as a tool and partner. They historically used prescribed burning, also called cultural burning, to prevent the coastal prairies from becoming overgrown with conifers and , the stems of which the Yurok use for basket weaving. Yet for much of the 20th century, Forest Service policy treated fire as a threat. 鈥淭hey considered fire arson,鈥 says Joe Hostler, who works in the Yurok Environmental Program鈥檚 community and ecosystems division. The Forest Service鈥檚 suppression of prescribed burning is 鈥渙ne of the reasons we have such overgrowth in our forests today,鈥 Hostler says.
Myers says this management approach is part of a colonial, Western perspective that views humans as separate from the natural world, rather than part of it. In contrast, he says that 鈥渙ne of the core tenets of our traditional ecological knowledge is [the idea that] nature is not natural without human interaction.鈥
Land reclamation with income from the cap-and-trade program has enabled the tribe to take control of its land management again and revitalize once-banned techniques like cultural burning. It has also allowed them to sustainably harvest timber for economic development and forest management, restore salmon habitats in the Klamath River watershed, and create farms to increase food sovereignty.
This is all part of the tribe鈥檚 climate change adaptation strategy. 鈥淭he climate change we are seeing now is unprecedented,鈥 Myers says. 鈥淏ut we still hold true to those same teachings that we [have held] since time immemorial.鈥
To establish the tribe鈥檚 vision of a more resilient future in a changing climate, Hostler interviewed elders about historical environmental conditions. They described a cool, clear, and clean Klamath River, healthy salmon runs, and vast forests of old-growth redwoods. These memories became the baseline of what the tribe now says a healthy environment should look like, and what they are working toward with their climate change adaptation plan.
鈥淲e are connected to our land,鈥 Hostler says. 鈥淲e have intimate knowledge of the landscape and intergenerational knowledge.鈥
Following in the Yurok鈥檚 footsteps, 13 other tribes and Alaska Native corporations from across the U.S. now participate in California鈥檚 cap-and-trade program, from the White Mountain Apache in Arizona to the Passamaquoddy in Maine. As of September 2020, were issued to tribes or Alaska Native Corporations for forest projects through California鈥檚 program; about half of all forest offset credits issued.
What is most important to Myers, though, is that the Yurok鈥檚 participation in California鈥檚 cap-and-trade program has strengthened tribal members鈥 relationship to their traditional territory. 鈥淭he most beneficial thing we鈥檙e doing with our land is giving members access to it,鈥 he says. 鈥淭hat is the greatest benefit we鈥檝e done with our land.鈥
Abaki Beck
is a public health graduate student and freelance writer. She writes about Indigenous feminism, Indigenous science and knowledge, and gender-based violence in Native communities.
|